BOXSCORE: 1912 New York Giants At 1912 Philadelphia Phillies         9/5/1912

  Giants             AB  R  H RBI AVG     Phillies           AB  R  H RBI AVG
  J.Devore RF         4  1  1  1 .312     D.Paskert CF        5  0  0  0 .327  
  L.Doyle 2B          3  1  1  2 .353     G.Cravath RF        5  2  2  1 .266  
  F.Snodgrass CF      4  0  1  0 .243     S.Magee LF          5  0  2  0 .320  
  R.Murray LF         4  0  0  0 .289     F.Luderus 1B        5  2  3  4 .287  
  F.Merkle 1B         4  0  2  0 .296     J.Walsh 2B,C        5  0  3  2 .277  
  B.Herzog 3B         4  0  2  0 .253     M.Doolin SS         3  0  1  0 .290  
  A.Wilson C          4  0  1  0 .281     J.Dodge 3B          4  0  0  0 .125  
B-T.Shafer PR         0  1  0  0 .302     A.Brennan P         0  0  0  0 .183  
D-G.Hartley C         0  0  0  0 .000     B.Killefer C        2  0  0  0 .192  
  A.Fletcher SS       4  2  2  0 .261   A-O.Knabe PH,2B       2  1  1  0 .274  
  R.Ames P            2  1  0  0 .222     P.Alexander P       3  1  1  0 .268  
  D.Crandall P        1  0  1  1 .500   C-H.Lobert 3B         1  1  1  0 .319  
                     -- -- -- ---                            -- -- -- ---      
         Totals      34  6 11  4                 Totals      40  7 14  7

A-Pinch Hit For Killefer In 7th Inning
B-Pinch Ran For Wilson In 9th Inning
C-Subbed Defensively (3B) For Alexander In 9th Inning
D-Subbed Defensively (C ) For Shafer In 9th Inning

Giants.......... 0 0 2  0 2 0  0 0 2  -  6 11  4
Phillies........ 0 0 0  0 0 0  1 3 3  -  7 14  3

Giants (85-40)           IP       H   R  ER  BB  SO  HR    ERA  SCORESHEET
R.Ames                    7 1/3   7   3   3   0   5   0   3.34  A1 D2
D.Crandall L(11-5)B(8th)  1       7   4   3   1   1   1   3.58  D3
Totals                    8 1/3  14   7   6   1   6   1

Phillies (52-74)         IP       H   R  ER  BB  SO  HR    ERA  SCORESHEET
P.Alexander               8 2/3  10   6   2   1   7   1   4.09  A1 D8
A.Brennan WIN(10-6)       0 1/3   1   0   0   0   1   0   3.51  D9
Totals                    9      11   6   2   1   8   1

ATTENDANCE- 1,240 DATE- Thursday, September 5th 1912 TIME- Day WEATHER- Good
UMPIRES- Cy Rigler, , , Bill Brennan
T- 2:28
LEFT ON BASE- Giants: 4  Phillies: 8
DOUBLE PLAYS- Giants: 1  Phillies: 3
ERRORS- L.Doyle, F.Merkle, A.Fletcher-2, G.Cravath, J.Dodge, B.Killefer
DOUBLES- S.Magee(19th), F.Luderus(23rd), J.Walsh(5th), P.Alexander
HOME RUNS- L.Doyle(11th), F.Luderus(7th)
RBIs- J.Devore(45th), L.Doyle-2(84th), D.Crandall(8th), G.Cravath(72nd),
      F.Luderus-4(80th), J.Walsh-2(9th)
STOLEN BASES- B.Herzog(39th)
CAUGHT STEALING- B.Herzog
SACRIFICE HITS- R.Ames
SACRIFICE FLIES- J.Devore
WALKS- L.Doyle, M.Doolin
STRIKE OUTS- J.Devore-2, F.Snodgrass, R.Murray-2, A.Wilson-2, R.Ames, G.Cravath,
             S.Magee-2, J.Dodge-2, B.Killefer
GIDP- R.Murray, B.Herzog-2, D.Paskert
2-out RBI- F.Luderus-3, D.Crandall
RLISP 2-out- F.Luderus, R.Murray, A.Fletcher, O.Knabe, J.Dodge
TEAM RISP- Giants: 1 for 6  Phillies: 7 for 16

With the crowd on their collective feet, screaming at the top of their lungs,
Philadelphia Phillies rallied to top New York Giants by the score of 7 to
6.

Philadelphia scored the decisive runs in a big bottom of the 9th inning
scoring 3 runs on 5 base hits.  Otto Knabe led off and keyed the rally when
he laced a one-base hit, and an error was also committed.  Hans Lobert next
to the plate and he delivered a base-hit.  After an out was recorded, Gavvy
Cravath then reached on an error knocking in a run.  Sherry Magee followed
and he ripped a base-hit to load the bases.  Fred Luderus stepped into the
box and slapped a one-base hit bringing in another run.  Jimmy Walsh added to
the rally and slapped a single making Philadelphia the winners and sending
the 1,240 fans home happy.  Philadelphia ended up with 14 hits for the game
while New York had 11.  

The win went to Ad Brennan(10-6) who allowed no runs in 1/3 of an inning. Doc
Crandall(11-5) was the loser in relief.  He gave up 4 runs and 7 hits in 1
inning.

SCORESHEET: 1912 New York Giants at 1912 Philadelphia Phillies
J.Devore-A1  A1:K       B1:SF+E/9  C1:Si      D1:G/43    E1:K
                        >3# 2# b3                        
                                                         
L.Doyle-A1   A2:W>b1    B2:G/43    C2:HR>1#   *8*:G/31
                                   b#         
                                              
F.Snodgr-A1  A3:Force/  B3:K       C3:Si      D3:L/3
             64>1o b1                         
                                              
R.Murray-A1  A4:G/53    B4:K       C4:G-DP/5  D4:K
                                   43>1o      
                                              
F.Merkle-A1  *2*:F/8    *4*:G/3    *6*:Si     *9*:Si
                                              
                                              
B.Herzog-A1  A6:Si      B6:Si      C6:G-DP/6  D6:G-DP/5
                                   43>1o      43>1o
                                              
A.Wilson-A1  A7:P/6 CS  B7:SB>12   C7:K       D7:Si
T.Shafer-D8  /24>1o     K                     
G.Hartle-E2                                   
A.Fletch-A1  *3*:Si     B8:L/5     *7*:G/63   D8:Si+E/5
                                              >1#
                                              
R.Ames-A1    A9:E/24>1  *5*:K      C9:G/53    D9:Si>3#
D.Cranda-D5  3 b2                             
                                              

D.Pasker-A1  A1:F/8     B1:G-DP/6  C1:G/63    D1:G/53    E1:P/4
                        43>1o                            
                                                         
G.Cravat-A1  A2:K       *4*:F/7    C2:Si      D2:Si>23   E2:E/6>3#
                                                         12 
                                                         
S.Magee-A1   A3:Do      B3:G/43    C3:K       D3:K       E3:Si>23
                                                         12
                                                         
F.Luderu-A1  A4:G/43    B4:F/8     *7*:Do     D4:HR>3#   E4:Si>3#
                                              1# b#      23 12
                                                         
J.Walsh-A1   *2*:P/3    *5*:P/3    C5:Do>2#   D5:Si+E/3  E5:Si>3#
                                                         23 12
                                                         
M.Doolin-A1  A6:G/53    B6:Si      C6:L/5     D6:IW>b1
                                              
                                              
J.Dodge-A1   A7:F/9     B7:K       C7:K       D7:G/63
A.Brenna-D8                                   
                                              
B.Killef-A1  *3*:K      B8:G/13    C8:G/63    *9*:Si+E/
O.Knabe-C8                                    4
                                              
P.Alexan-A1  A9:E/6     *6*:L/4    *8*:Do     D9:Si>23
H.Lobert-D8